channel33: star cut lantern (starcut lantern)
Pourquoi nous ne voulons pas du tourisme comme priorité nationale…


Nous n’avons pas la prétention de parler au nom de la population mauricienne, mais nous pouvons, par contre parler en tant que citoyen mauricien. Et nous ne voulons pas du tourisme comme priorité nationale car cela fait des décennies que cette industrie est une priorité nationale pour les Gouvernements successifs et le secteur privé. Et le résultat est navrant. Au vu du constat ce n’est certainement pas une telle priorité qu’il faut. Tout au contraire : nous pensons que c’est l’industrie du tourisme ainsi que nos chers décideurs qui doivent être remis à leurs places respectives car ils ont outrepassé leurs prérogatives.
En tout premier lieu il est clair que le tourisme a contribué grandement à l’essor économique et social du pays depuis plus de 50 ans. C’est une évidence. Nul besoin d’y retourner. Par contre cet essor a eu des couts environnementaux et sociaux qui furent longtemps ignorer voir ouvertement mépriser par l’industrie elle-même.
Ainsi, nous fumes effarer d’entendre un illustre personnage, grand connaisseur de l’industrie, ouvertement fanfaronner, dans un workshop international en 2002, et nous citons : « tourism cannot degrade the environment ». Nous exprimâmes notre désaccord à ce sujet. Nous eûmes l’honneur d’être traité de « larriaze » quand cette sommité quitta les lieux. L’incident est révélateur. Pendant trop longtemps l’industrie, les politiciens et les hauts fonctionnaires ont négligés l’impact environnemental du tourisme, des hôtels et des activités nautiques touristiques. Derrière de bien curieuses études d’impacts environnementaux (EIA) et nous avons eu loisirs d’en lire, le secteur privé et le gouvernement ont voulu croire que cette industrie n’avait rien à se reprocher.
A chaque fois que l’industrie touristique s’affolait, enfin, de la dégradation environnementale ils blâmaient trop souvent le laxisme des autorités, l’insouciance du public, tout saufs leurs propres activités. Pourtant l’épique bataille d’Ecosud (1997- 2001) et leurs alliés contre le projet de l’ile aux Deux Cocos rappelait à tous que la construction et l’opération d’hôtels avaient bien et bels des impacts environnementaux. Rappelons-nous aussi qu’à la même époque un groupe hôtelier voulait construire à La Prairie et que leur EIA affirmé que le lagon devrait être dragué car il étouffait (2001) ! Heureusement ce groupe eut excellente initiative de laisser tomber le projet et nous les en saluons !
Rappelons aussi qu’une des raisons de l’érosion côtière est bien le fait d’hôtels et de bungalows construits trop près du « high water mark ». N’oublions pas les activités nautiques sans cesse, une des causes de dégradation dans le lagon. Ajoutons l’impact diffus sur les lagons des eaux usagées ou des eaux des stations d’épurations en mal de fonctionnement. Notons, au passage, l’état désertique du parc marin de Balaclava que nous avons pu constater de visu en bateau avec des touristes auxquels on avait vanté la richesse de ce parc. Nous nous rappelons très bien qu’avant la construction d’hôtels dans les années 90, le foisonnement de vie aquatique là-bas. Par contre les coraux de Bel-Ombre sont toujours là, mais pour combien de temps ? Notons qu’a Bel Ombre (2002 -2005) nous avons eu droit à un EIA qui proclamait qu’on pouvait extirper des gros rochers de la plage pour ensuite voir les mêmes hôteliers se précipiter pour trouver des moyens de réduire l’érosion de leurs plages que ces mêmes rochers protégeaient.
Le constat se clarifie : l’industrie touristique ainsi que l’hôtellerie ont des impacts négatifs majeurs sur la qualité environnementale de ce pays. Hélas, l’industrie, dans son ensemble, ne semble pas prête d’accepter sa part de responsabilité, préférant se présenter comme victime et de blâmer les chiens errants, les carcasses de voitures et autres mauvaises herbes. Le manque de vision de l’industrie et du Gouvernement est évident quand on considère que depuis des années ceux-ci essaient désespérément de construire un hôtel sur l’ile aux bénitiers avec une élévation maximale d’un mètre au-dessus du niveau de la mer, donc inondable en temps cycloniques. Une absurdité ! Cet ilot devrait être transformé en réserve naturelle ne permettant que des visiteurs en journée.
Mais allons plus loin dans notre réflexion. L’industrie s’émerveillent du développement intégré de Bel Ombre. Nous nous émerveillons de la ségrégation que cela consolide dans notre pays. A droite les riches touristes et à gauche les indigènes. Et voilà que le même modèle de ségrégation est en train de s’ériger aux Salines. Nous nous insurgeons contre un tel type de développement.
Il aurait mieux fallut construire toute l’infrastructure hôtelière et autres en retrait du littoral laissant ainsi une large bande côtière de 80 mètres de profondeur à partie du High Water Mark (HWM) qui aurait été décréter plage publique accessible aux touristes et mauriciens. Apres tout l’hospitalité et la convivialité mauricienne, socle de notre économie, garantissent une cohabitation harmonieuse entre touristes et mauriciens. Un usage multiple d’un bien commun, le littoral, aurait été un réel agencement intégrer. De qui plus est, une large bande côtière aurait agi comme « buffer zone » contre les tempêtes et marées hautes.
Rien n’est acquis dans ce bas monde. Maurice ne peut plus se prévaloir de sa beauté naturelle ou de la gentillesse de sa population pour attirer le touriste car la compétition devient féroce, sans merci. Nous sommes dans une situation où trop de sites sont alloués pendant des années à des promoteurs invisibles pendant que le pays s’enlaidit et que l’espace public se rétrécit, que notre patrimoine s’érode, que le digital amplifie l’impact que toute dégradation a sur la destination. Les enjeux dépassent, et de très loin le tourisme. Il faut engager une stratégie à long terme avec l’adhésion de la population.
Ce que nous voulons n’est pas de faire du tourisme une priorité nationale, mais de faire le patrimoine culturel et naturel du pays ainsi que les zones côtières une priorité nationale.
Voici donc nos suggestions concernant cette priorité. Il faudrait (1) arrêter d’allouer des Pas Géométriques à des promoteurs hôteliers ou autres (2) re-déclaré publique la plage de Pomponette, (3) interdire toutes nouvelles constructions côtières sur les Pas Géométriques, (4) décréter plus de plages publiques permettant usages multiples, (5) transformer les plages publiques en zone verte avec de la végétation adéquate, (6) mettre en place une meilleure protection du patrimoine, matériel et immatériel et donc de relancer Port Louis by Night dès que possible, (7) développer une politique nationale pour les musées comprenant l’histoire navale, l’esclavage, les trains à vapeur d’antan par exemple, (8) protéger d’urgence le moulin à poudre de Pamplemousse livrer aux pillages actuellement (9) relancer l’artisanat de charpenterie marine qui se meurt, (10) avoir une politique d’ouverture publique des terres forestières et de balisage de sentiers forestiers, (11) élaborer une politique de pistes cyclables. (12) encourager nos historiens et chercheurs à publier des fascicules et livrets sur l’histoire de Maurice et de l’Océan Indien.
Nos propositions ne vont certainement pas séduire tout le monde mais l’important est d’émettre des suggestions pour encourager les autorités et le secteur privé à agir de manière plus sensée et équitable.
Karim Jaufeerally
channel33: star cut lantern (Default)
Is the World on the edge of a major war in West Asia (The Middle East)?

With the blatantly illegal attack on Iran by the US and Israel in February of this year, how far will the Empire go to topple the current Iranian Government in its quest to maintain hegemony? An overview of recent history is required to address that burning question.

The 20th century began with 2 major geopolitical events that are still shaping the world more than 100 years later. Notably World War I (WW1) and the Russian Bolshevik Revolution, these 2 events saw the collapse of several large empires such as the Austro-Hungarian, German, Ottoman and Russian Empires. World War 2 is a continuation of these 2 events. It saw the collapse of the Japanese Empire and the concomitant emergence of the United States of America (US) and the Soviet Union as super powers and the rise of Communist China (1948) as a major regional power. Those events brought about the collapse of the Colonial Empires of the United Kingdom (UK), France and the Netherlands.

A new era had begun. During WW1, in 1916, the UK and France had signed a secret pact, the Sykes Picot agreement, dividing West Asia (Middle East) into respective spheres of influence as they anticipated the fall of the Ottoman Empire that had ruled the region for about 400 years.

What the European powers wanted to avoid at all cost was the emergence of a powerful Arab state after the collapse of the Ottoman Empire. With an overall land mass of 3.7 million square kilometres and maybe 50 million people in 1920, any large Arab state in West Asia (The Middle East) could very well be a powerful challenger to European Hegemony. Hence the Sykes Picot Agreement. Oil had been discovered in Persia (modern day Iran) in 1908 and it was becoming essential for most modern form of transportations, especially maritime ships, inclusive of navies. Presumably the European Colonial powers of the time must have suspected that more oil were to be discovered in the region.

West Asia was also very important as a gateway to the rest of Asia, Africa and Europe via the Suez Canal and other trade routes. The strategic importance of West Asia was considerable, to say the least. In that perspective, the Balfour declaration of 1917 (whereby the then British Foreign Secretary Arthur Balfour offered to Lord Walter Rothschild British support for a "national home for the Jewish people" in Palestine) takes on a new twist. Most probably, the British Government of the time decided to instrumentalise Jewish Zionism to set up a proxy European Colonial Jewish state in the heart of Arab lands. The purpose was to protect British interests by disrupting any attempts to create a large Arab state.

This policy of divide to rule worked wonderfully well as West Asia has stayed fragmented and in the grips of intermittent wars ever since. Nevertheless, WW2 proved catastrophic for the British Empire as it began to unravel fairly quickly once the war was over. In the meantime, large oil and natural gas fields had been discovered in Iraq, Saudi Arabia, Qatar and the United Arab Emirates. The strategic importance of West Asia was now obvious to all.

The second event that shook the world during WW1 was the Russian Revolution. It was a direct attack on the rich and powerful who had never felt so threatened since the French revolution of 1789. This successful revolution inspired many across Europe and its European colonies, including in West Asia (Middle East). There were a number of socialist upheavals or revolutions across West Asia and North Africa in the fifties and sixties, notably in Egypt, Libya, Syria, Iraq and Iran.

The Arab Monarchies took fright and quickly realised that only the US was powerful enough to protect them from socialist revolutions. Defence Alliances between Arab Monarchies and the US were now inevitable. Furthermore, the US has always been very hostile to any socialist or communist governments. Hence there was a natural tendency for Arab Monarchies to drift towards the US, after all, monarchies do not tend to be socialist nor communist! This alliance consolidated in 1973 – 1974 when Nixon stopped the convertibility of US dollars into gold as this mechanism was draining the gold reserves of the US. Instead all international oil purchases were henceforth to be settled in US dollars. This move, led by Saudi Arabia, guaranteed a continued demand for US dollars.

It was a mutually beneficial arrangement: the oil producing Gulf States sell in dollars which are then re-injected in the US economy, in return they are offered military protection by the US whose economy benefit from a large influx of dollars. This arrangement has allowed the US to ramp up a huge trade deficit and an equally large Federal Debt financed by US Treasury bonds. The US could also outspend any other power on the planet in terms of military budgets. The Petro-Dollar was born. This arrangement made sense as besides the US no other country in the world at that time had a powerful enough economy to handle the considerable influxes of capital involved.

Then came the Iranian Islamic Revolution which overthrew the Shah of Iran in 1979. This dealt a significant blow to the regional US power structure, for since the collapse of the Ottoman Empire, few regional countries were free from Western hegemony. Immediately and ever since, successive US administrations have maintained and expanded sanctions against Iran and have conspired to destroy Iran. For instance, the Iran – Iraq war of 1980 – 1988 was partially instigated by the US and other European countries. However, the war ended with a stalemate. That historical fact shows the resilience of Iran. A lesson worth remembering today.

In an interview a four star US general in retirement reported that in 2001, the then Bush administration was planning to attack at least four countries in West Asia over the next few years, notably Iraq (2003), Syria (2011 – 2024), Libya (2011), and Iran (2025-2026). It appears that a long term strategy was being prepared by the Bush administration of the time to conquer and subjugate West Asia and that this plan was and is being implemented across different US administrations, whether democrat or republican.

With the rise of China as the de facto challenger of the US and with the emergence of Russia as a superpower in the wake of the collapse of the Soviet Union, the need to maintain hegemony over West Asia is even more pressing. China requires both West Asia and Russia's oil and gas thus the US needs to keep control over these vital resources to remain relevant in the current state of world affairs.

The situation for the US becomes even more pressing with the establishment of the BRICS alliance that regroups Brazil, Russia, India, China, South Africa, Egypt, Ethiopia, Iran, Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and Indonesia.

What began as a diplomatic forum for emerging markets and developing countries has quickly become a platform for economic cooperation and for a decreased reliance on the US dollar. US hegemony is now at risk and the US counter strategy is simple: break Iran to break up the BRICS alliance and then confront Russia and China. This may well be the strategy of the current Trump administration too, in direct line with its predecessors. Presumably, China and Russia are perfectly aware of that. Hence, the iron clad support they provide Iran. The stakes are high. Israel, as the US's attack dog, enthusiastically support this aggressive strategy as in return it believes it can dominate West Asia and that its security can only be assured when its neighbours are weak and divided. It is an unwise belief because without unconditional US support Israel cannot dominate West Asia. Any US strategic failure and Israel becomes weak and highly vulnerable and may be left twisting in the wind.

The illegal and unjustified attack on Iran of February 2026 has shown the resilience of Iran and its people. It is turning out that Iran is a tough nut to crack as it was in the 1980 – 1988 war. Trump has announced an indefinite cease fire. How truthful is the US remains to be seen given the above mentioned strategy. Future attacks by the US cannot be ruled out. Furthermore, if Iran does not falter, the use of nuclear devices by the US or Israel against that country is a possibility, especially given the utter contempt and disdain for non-western life these two countries have displayed over the years.

Ever since the fall of the Soviet Union, the world has been dominated by the US, its vassals and proxies. The simultaneous rise of both Russia and China coupled with the emergence of the BRICS have challenged the old unipolar world order, a multi polar world now appears to be in the works. This change of the Guard may well be unstoppable. Either the US accepts a more balanced distribution of world power or it does everything it can to slow down the rise of this new multipolar world.

In a way, the US is caught between a hammer and a hard place. There are 2 broad choices (1) the US backs off from world hegemony then loses dominance, the US dollar ceases to be the prime world currency, it defaults on its debt and standards of living in the US drops significantly. (2) The US does a "fuite en avant" and continues its endless wars to a horrific end.

Interestingly enough, it could well be that the Trump administration is still unsure of what path to choose. Ever since the February attack on Iran, Trump has called for multiple cease fires. Victorious countries do not do that in times of war. It is possible that the Trump administration has come to the conclusion that to defeat Iran will involve such destruction across West Asia that the consequences will be catastrophic for everybody US included. If so, it might just possible that the current administration has decided that a gradual and controlled down scaling from world hegemony is a goal well worth pursuing. Only time will tell.


Published in Mauritius newspapers on the 11th of May 2026

Karim Jaufeerally
channel33: star cut lantern (starcut lantern)
An Open Letter to the Government of Mauritius concerning matters of interest to the Republic and its citizens.

(1) The Killing Fields of Gazah and Mauritius
The Israeli Government is currently carrying out a war of annihilation against the Gazah civilian population with more than 53,000 recorded dead, most of whom are women and children. Undoubtedly, many more lie under the rubble. Furthermore the Israeli Government has stopped nearly all aid from reaching Gazah creating a precarious humanitarian situation that is slowly inching towards famine. In itself this constitutes a war crime of immense proportion.
This artificially and deliberately created famine is an attempt at genocide, a situation that is intolerable and violates all known moral standards. We would like to remind Government that the last time a civilian population was deliberately starved to death was during WW2 when Germans imprisoned several thousand Eastern European Jews in the Ghetto of Warsaw in occupied Poland. Thereafter, following a brave and courageous uprising the Ghetto was attacked by German troops and inmates liquidated by sending them to notorious death camps. The parallel with the current situation in Gazah is obvious and ghastly beyond measure.
In light of the above and given that Mauritius has open and cordial relations with Israel, We would like to know whether Government is considering reviewing its current stance towards Israel and whether it will take any steps to distance itself from a country willingly and knowingly carrying out massacres of civilians and transforming Gazah into killing fields.

(2) Mauritius and the case of South Africa at the International Court of Justice
In December 2023, South Africa has brought a case against Israel before the International Court of Justice (ICJ) alleging genocide in Gaza. Given that Mauritius has benefited of the support of many countries across the world, including South Africa, in its successful legal battle for the recognition of its sovereignty over the Chagos Archipelago, We, therefore, would like to know whether Mauritius will contribute alongside South Africa to this important case in International Law by making oral or written submissions before the ICJ. Note that in the name of Truth, Justice, and Human Dignity it is a moral imperative that Mauritius contributes to this case before the ICJ. Absence of submissions to the ICJ may be hugely damaging to the standing of Mauritius worldwide and History may pass a severe and final judgement on the failure to do so.
(3) The Chagos Archipelago and the UK and Mauritius Deal
(a)After a protracted, extraordinary and ultimately successful legal case, Mauritius has seen its full sovereignty recognised by the United Nations Assembly, thus forcing the United Kingdom (UK) in engaging in meaningful high level talks with Mauritius on this issue.
After the General Elections of November 2024, the current Mauritian and British Governments initiated talks about the effective return of the Chagos Archipelago to Mauritius over sight and control, save for the Diego Garcia main island where the UK-US naval base is situated. Although details are sparse, it appears that Government has agreed to lease the Diego Garcia Island to the UK for an extended period of time and for an undisclosed but albeit large sum of money.
In doing so, the Mauritian Government legalises and legitimises the presence of the US and UK naval base on Mauritian territory. This base has been systematically presented by the UK as essential to its security. Alas, the historical record shows very clearly that this base has been used to attack countries across the Middle East / West Asia, such as Irak (1991, 2003), Afghanistan (2001), Yemen (2024, 2025). It is evident that the true purpose of the base is to project United States’ (US) Imperial power in order to dominate and subjugate the region thereby causing immense misery and spreading death and destruction to millions of people. By legitimising the base on Diego Garcia, Mauritius becomes, willing and consciously, an accomplice of US Imperial Policy. This is morally repugnant and therefore unacceptable.
(b)Furthermore, it is known that the US base houses many nuclear weapons in either submarines, ships or cruise missiles. However, Mauritius is a signatory to The African Nuclear-Weapon-Free Zone Treaty (the Pelindaba Treaty) that came into force in 2009. We quote: “The African Nuclear-Weapon-Free Zone Treaty prohibits the research, development, manufacture, stockpiling, acquisition, testing, and possession, control or stationing of nuclear weapons, as well as the dumping of radioactive wastes. The Treaty also prohibits any attack against nuclear installations in the zone by Treaty parties and requires them to maintain the highest standards of physical protection of nuclear material, facilities and equipment, which are to be used exclusively for peaceful purposes.” (source: https://www.un.org/nwfz/content/treaty-pelindaba)
In that perspective, recognition of the Diego Garcia base by Government would mean that it is agreeable to the US stationing nuclear weapons on Mauritian territory and thus may well be infringing provisions of this treaty. It is not acceptable that Mauritius becomes a renegade State for the sake of large sums of money and contributes to making the Indian Ocean Region unsafe.
(c)On Friday the 13th of June 2025, Israel launched an unprovoked and probable illegal aerial attack on military and civil nuclear installations of the Islamic Republic of Iran. The latter has begun retaliation by launching missiles attacks on Israel. The situation can potentially escalate and could result in the direct involvement of US and UK armed forces. In that perspective, the use of the Diego Garcia base to bomb Iran is inevitable. Thus any recognition by Mauritius of the UK-US base makes Mauritius a co-belligerent, a highly unenviable situation for such a small country devoid of any meaningful defences. Furthermore, should this conflict widen and involve more countries, it is not fanciful to imagine that mainland Mauritius may become a potential target of military action. In that case, this Government has, potentially, placed Mauritius in a dangerous situation to an unprecedented degree.
In conclusion we urge the Mauritius Government to urgently (1) review our links with Israel, (2) consider submissions to the ICJ alongside South Africa, and (3) refrain from signing any deals concerning the US – UK naval base.

Karim Jaufeerally
channel33: star cut lantern (Default)
As Modern Industrial Civilisation continues its decline due to depletion of fossil fuels, environmental degradation and climate change, the need to steer the country towards sustainability becomes ever more pressing. Etymologically, the word sustainability comes from the Latin word: sustinere which means to “hold and maintain things from below”. Indeed, what we all want to sustain and maintain over the long term is human civilisation.

Civilisation ought to be humane, cultured and sustainable meaning that (1) a humane civilisation is one in which society acts so that individuals are able to meet their basic needs for food, water, energy, shelter and are granted a minimum of basic rights, (2) a cultured civilisation is one that gives reasonable opportunities to its members to access the cultural resources available to it and that means its knowledge and skill bases, whether written or oral, formal or informal, (3) a sustainable civilisation is one which does not undermine its own resource base via inconsiderate actions and short term thinking so characteristic of modern times.

This article focuses on the basic needs for decent and affordable housing in Mauritius. It is an accepted reality of Mauritius that there is a growing housing crisis. It mainly affects the poor to middle income social strata. But now it is slowly inching its way up the social ladder given that higher income families are finding it increasingly difficult to acquire a decent piece of land and find the necessary financial resources to build a house on it.

The priority of Government being foreign direct investment, the focus is on attracting high net worth foreigners or Mauritians interested in purchasing luxurious villas at astronomical prices clearly out of reach of nearly everyone else. It is interesting to note how fully functional democracies can result in Governments that are more interested in the welfare of the rich than that of the masses of people who elected those very same Governments in the first place. Adding insult to injury, those same Governments are then re-elected regularly by the impoverished masses.

With such a system rigidly in place for decades now, it is not surprising that the country is heading for a housing crisis resulting in much misery for the majority with no end in sight. The negative social, health and psychological impacts of the housing crisis surely extract heavy costs onto the country. Alas, few economists seem to have computed such costs. Presumably their main centres of interest lie elsewhere.

Nevertheless from a humanistic perspective, it is not acceptable to let fellow citizens to endure over-crowded living spaces indefinitely.

It would be absurd to believe that the housing crisis can be satisfactorily resolved by a few measures here and there. It cannot. But the methodical, rational and reasonable application of certain principles can go far in addressing the situation. This is what is proposed here. Sustainability begins at home and therefore any serious attempts to make society sustainable should begin there also. So what would a sustainable household look like? In Mauritius most households are made up of 3 to 5 persons generally a couple with children together with an elder relative. Comfortable living means 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, a kitchen, and a combined living and dinning room and a storage room or laundry space or garage giving a total surface area of under 200 square meters. Such a house would consist of a ground floor plus a first floor making a footprint of 100 square meters.

Together with the house, there would be a garden to allow residents to make compost with their organic wastes, a vegetable plot, fruit trees and a safe area for children to play. On the roof a solar water heater and photo-voltaic panels. The roof is used for rain water harvesting. A plot of land of 400 square meters or 100 toises (an ancien regime land measurement dating from the time when Mauritius was a French colony) is sufficient for such a housing unit. The basis of household sustainability is set.

Construction costs of the above basic house could vary considerably given that large scale constructions of residential units by government can bring down costs significantly. It is best to leave construction costs estimates to experienced professionals. The land area required for this project, however, can be estimated.

In 2020, the Mauritian population was about 1,266,000 with about 365,000 households. Each household should have its own house. From anecdotal evidence, it is fair to assume that roughly one third of the population would benefit from relocation to new houses.

Hence 120,000 housing units ought to be built each on a plot of land of 400 square meters requiring 4800 hectares of land. This must be increased by 30% to make up for access roads, public amenities such as bicycle lanes, social centres, police stations and public gardens resulting in approximately 6400 hectares of land. It is a large chunk of real estate no doubt but certainly not impossible to obtain for a country of 200,000 hectares given that the 6400 hectares required represent about 3% of the total surface area. First time home-buyers ought to be given priority, especially couples with small children.

If planned intelligently by taking in consideration public transport issues, existing electric, water, sewage networks, health and educational facilities then those new urban areas could turn out to be pleasant and comfortable to live in whilst avoiding over crowding and other social dynamics that reliably lead to urban decay.

Given that large tracts of land across the country would be needed, it is inevitable that some of the land required would come from the sugar cane industry, the largest real estate owner in Mauritius. It is a particular aspect of the history of Mauritius that there never have been any significant land reforms in this country after independence.

This lack of land reform will have to be addressed one way or the other. New urban areas may well be a reasonable manner to carry out a land reform which could be the country’s ticket to long lasting social peace in a global era of turbulence and instability. People who have a decent place to live and raise children may not be particularly interested in taking to the streets and revolt. Furthermore with a vegetable garden contributing to the food security of the family, each household may well become a vector for sustainability which really begins in the kitchen. Needles to say, decent and affordable housing is a significant factor in poverty alleviation.
With a little imagination and good will, those new urban areas could also accommodate small retail businesses or workshops, service providers, food stalls, local markets and fairs while social centres may provide much needed recreational and cultural events at affordable costs to the neighbourhoods. The list is endless.

In conclusion, Government and the private sector ought to understand that decent and affordable housing is one of the most cost effective responses to address social inequity, create social peace and embark on the long road to sustainability. Concerned parties should note that time is slowly running out.
channel33: star cut lantern (Default)
The Age of Consequences and a vision of the future…

Our modern civilization, through its gargantuan appetite for natural resources and its propensity to generate wastes and pollution, has unleashed a number of dynamics which are now severe enough to impact on human welfare worldwide. These dynamics are (1) Climate Change, (2) Resource & Energy Depletion and (3) Environmental Degradation which henceforth will be referred to as the CREED dynamics.

(1) Climate Change. Since the industrial revolution our civilisation has been pumping billions of tonnes of carbon dioxide (CO2) into the atmosphere from the use of fossil fuels. CO2 is a greenhouse gas that traps solar radiation within the atmosphere and turns this radiation into thermal energy (heat). This additional heat inevitably works its way through the planetary climatic and oceanic systems thereby causing extremes of weather like more powerful storms, more rainfall in some places or drought in others and raises sea levels and global temperatures.

(2) Environmental degradation is characterised by a decline in soil fertility, a decline in fisheries, water crisis, and loss of biodiversity, land and water pollution. Currently 40% of land worldwide is seriously degraded whilst substantially degraded land may climb to 95% by 2050. World forestry cover has declined from 50% before the industrial revolution to about 30% now. Over fishing affect 30% of fish stocks and 60% to 90% of oceans are over-exploited. By 2050 most fisheries will have collapsed on current trends.
Water scarcity now affects one-third of humanity increasing to two-thirds by 2025,
80% of waste water worldwide is dumped into the environment untreated. Plastic waste pollution is everywhere on the planet with microscopic plastic debris found in many animals. There is a gradual loss of biodiversity worldwide. It has been estimated that a 100 to 1000 species go extinct each year, a far greater number than the natural extinction rate. Taken together these are hall marks of a decline in the environment worldwide.

(3) Energy Depletion. 80% of world energy consumption comes from either, coal, oil or natural gas, the main contributors to CO2 emissions. In spite of considerable efforts worldwide, human civilisation is largely unable to reduce its fossil fuel consumption significantly. Upsurges in renewable energy production may not cause a dramatic reduction in demand for fossil energy. Only when fossil fuel resources will have been severely depleted thereby causing a reduction in supply that fossil fuel consumption will decline. It is probable that the world is fast approaching that point for oil supplies.

(4) Resource depletion. This least visible parameter refers to non-fossil fuels mineral supply. Although mineral scarcity is not yet apparent, humankind’s voracious appetite for minerals keeps on increasing. There is a worldwide search for new sources of ores that fuels war and destitution as can be seen in Central Africa.

World population has reached 7.5 billion humans and may reach 9 billion by 2050. Rising prosperity means increased demands for food, energy, water and other resources. Pressures on the environment will remain high into the foreseeable future. CREED dynamics will therefore continue apace. In short, our civilisation is slowly eroding its resource bases and is in over-shoot.

In that context, it is likely that the world’s ability to produce enough food for all will be reduced. Food prices may rise together with shortages. The poor will suffer most and first. Hunger or malnutrition may rise. Energy depletion may cause large spikes in oil prices and could lead to shortages. Oil is indispensable for modern transportation systems and agro-chemicals. High oil prices and / or shortages may result in poor economic growth or depressions and impact food prices with severe social consequences leading to unrests, revolutions or wars. We have well and truly entered an age of consequences of our own making.

The triple crisis of 2008 – 2010 which combined a financial meltdown with food and oil prices hikes caused immense human suffering across the planet. In Mauritius there were significant drops in tourism arrivals and revenue. This triple crisis had many causes but to some extent it was also the resultant of high oil prices, triggered by the difficulty of many oil producing countries in increasing oil production to dampen high oil prices. This crisis is a foretaste of what is in store for us. This time round the world was lucky because of (a) the rapid injection of unlimited funds into the failing financial system by the central banks of rich countries and (b) the rapid rise of US light tight oil production as from 2007 onwards which managed to prevent a significant reduction in oil supplies worldwide and so prepared the way for the oil price collapse of 2014.

These two factors did much to save the decade of 2010 – 2020. It is possible that US light tight oil production may reach a plateau within the next few years before a gradual decline sets in as the resource is depleted. Should that be the case, further oil price hikes are very likely in the years to come. The basic model of future crisis may well be along the lines of financial instability together with high food and oil prices, water scarcity followed by economic depression. A period of recuperation characterised by lower food and oil prices may follow until a new crisis comes along. With each round of crisis, our economic and material welfare may be reduced measurably generating more poverty world-wide. Our civilisation begins its decline. In our model, we ignore the real possibility of major warfare among powerful countries. Such events are very difficult to predict and can only accelerate decline.
Although we paint a rather bleak picture of the future that many will reject out of hand, at all levels of society much can be done to mitigate the impacts of such crisis.

We have argued that our modern industrial civilization has generated a number of dynamics such as climate change, environmental degradation, energy and resource depletion which are now impacting human welfare worldwide. In short our civilisation is in over-shoot. These dynamics are probably unstoppable given the momentum they have acquired by now. These dynamics generate food, energy and water crisis that come and go, together with serious economic & financial difficulties. Taken together these crises can reduce human welfare.

These are hallmarks of a decline in our civilization. We should not be surprised of our situation; after all, historically civilizations emerge, grow, reach maturity, and then decline. This is what happened to the Western Roman Empire, the Egyptian, Chinese civilizations amongst many others. Once in full decline, other civilizations rise and the cycle continues anew.

It is likely that we are now living through the opening phases of decline of our own modern industrial civilization. Note that decline is not a fast and abrupt phenomenon. It can unfold over several decades or even centuries. The next few decades from 2020 – 2050 will probably be critical. Much can be done to slow decline and soften impacts.

Common sense dictates that such a project of containing decline ought to be driven by Government and supported by citizens. Alas Government and the corporate world are both locked into a trance that limits their scope of action. Briefly, both Governments and corporations are committed to economic growth at any costs because their survival is dependent on delivering welfare to voters and profits to shareholders. Hence both entities are chained to a short term mode of thinking that relies mainly on high – tech, market based and financially profitable responses.

Yet tackling many of the dynamics of decline requires that economic growth and profitability ought to take a back seat from time to time and that a longer view of human welfare be contemplated. Although we acknowledge that both Governments and the corporate world are beginning to change their approach to both environmental degradation and climate change, they still do not seem to grasp that our civilisation is in over-shoot and in danger of decline.

Hence government and corporate sector’s responses are somehow inadequate. The top down approach has reached its limits. The lack of real action on the climate change front is an obvious example. The failure of COP 25 in Madrid in December 2019 demonstrates this point since nearly everybody from governments to large corporations and institutions worldwide agreed about the urgency of climate change. Furthermore no significant and voluntary reductions on green-house gases emissions have been noted and a point of no return has probably been breached by climatic systems a long time ago. The COVID 19 pandemic and the subsequent lock downs worldwide did reduce greenhouse gasses emissions significantly, but they were not voluntary and resulted in economic hardships. Given that the pandemic is largely over, greenhouse gasses emissions will probably resume their upward march.

Thus much will have to rely on local citizen actions. The overall approach is to find acceptable local alternatives as substitutes for imported goods and services where feasible. The goal is NOT to become self-sufficient in everything, that would be both unrealistic and detrimental to the population. However, there is much that can be done here and now without living in destitution and misery. Let us explore some of these avenues of local citizen action.

Food is a priority. Mauritius imports 80% of its foodstuff and this ratio shows no sign of going down. This dependency on imports is a major weakness for the country.

Yet, from the consumers’ perspective, food in Mauritius can be expensive. An obvious response is for individual citizens to begin composting their kitchen wastes and growing fruits and vegetables if circumstances permit. Widespread home composting by citizens will do much to reduce solid wastes problems whilst improving soil fertility. Over the past years we have noted an upsurge in home composting and in the number of small enterprises that have sprung to grow organic vegetables or establish nurseries. It is an encouraging trend.

However, much of our food security will depend on our ability to grow more starchy foods like potatoes, manioc or breadfruit. Although we do not believe that we shall soon face a situation of shortages in either rice or wheat, prices could increase dramatically as in 2008. Wherever possible, growing starchy staples will mitigate impacts of high food prices on house hold budgets.

In any supermarket, we find large selections of imported processed foods like biscuits, jams, cakes, ice creams for instance. It would be advantageous for citizens to reduce where possible purchases of imported items and prefer locally processed foods instead. That will enable more foreign exchange to remain in the country. Furthermore, cooking from basic ingredients make costs go down, savings made and useful skills learned.

Another avenue of action would be food preservation in time of plenty with pickles, jams, dried or frozen vegetables. Home bread making and bakery are within the reach of most households.

Caution is advised when buying consumer electronics such as cell phones and computers. The eagerness for consumers to buy such goods is unreasonable. It is preferable to use existing electronic devices until they are beyond repair and to be very wary of falling for new versions of devices that do exactly what the previous versions did at premium prices.

Clothing and apparel purchases should also be scrutinised carefully. Let us give precedence over local brands rather than imported ones.

Finally, let us find contentment with what we have now rather than seeking more material possessions tomorrow. The rush of excitement we feel when shopping is ephemeral and superficial. Long lasting contentment is generated when we regain initiatives in our lives. This can be achieved by increasing our knowledge base, skills and aptitudes. All of the above may seem pitifully inadequate given the dynamics at hand. Yet with each seed planted, each ounce of compost produced, each home made biscuit cooked, we steer a path away from a harsh decline and make way for a gentler future. It is interesting to note that the COID 19 crisis has shown that resilience is a local affair and so is sustainability. Let us all take note of that.

Karim Jaufeerally
channel33: star cut lantern (Default)
Over the years there has been mention of sustainable tourism in the higher spheres of Government and the private sector in Mauritius. Indeed there even is an international day for world sustainable tourism held on the 2nd of June of each year.

There also is a Government project, Sustainable Island Project, partly financed by the European Union whose avowed target is to transform Mauritius into a green destination. From what can be read in the press, the project is having significant positive impacts on energy efficiencies, use of renewable energies, food wastes and elimination of plastic wastes in tourist enterprises amongst other benefits.

All of the above is quite welcomed as the tourism industry is a high consumption industry that devours resources, energy and public spaces whilst generating large volumes of polluting solid and liquid wastes, creating social conflicts, impacting considerably marine and land based biodiversity. In short, although the tourism industry generates much needed revenue and employment it is also very good at making a nuisance of itself due to its insatiable appetite for public lands and resources gotten at cheap rates from Government.

Furthermore it does not appear that the considerable impacts of this industry on the social and environmental fabric of this country are ever mentioned by Government or the European Union. On the contrary, the public is invited to rejoice in the magnificent march of the tourism industry in becoming green, sustainable and environmentally friendly whilst generating the all important growth that will now be more inclusive of the citizen. How convincing this message is to the local populace is unknown.



However successful the Sustainable Island Project may be, it could be largely irrelevant to making tourism sustainable because sustainable tourism may well be an oxymoron, at least concerning long haul tourism that ferries tourists from Europe to Mauritius and back. Indeed, each passenger from Europe is responsible for the emission of between 1 to 2 tons of CO2 for the 2-way trip. How sustainable is that? Note that the 25% increase in fuel efficiency of new jet engines will not change much to the situation.

It is interesting to note that on one hand Government and the European Union are openly worried about the potentially devastating impacts of increased CO2 emissions on the dynamics of climate change whilst on the other hand they are doing their level best to promote long haul tourism that emits large quantities of CO2. May be Government or the European Union do not really believe in their own climate change rhetoric or it is serious delusional and disorderly thinking on behalf of critically important institutions.

However serious is this delusional thinking, it is not the gravest failings of these institutions. There is far worse. It is an established fact that oil, from which jet fuel is made, is a non-renewable and finite fossil fuel and hence subject to relentless depletion. This means that with each barrel of oil extracted from the ground there is one barrel less left for future use. Oil is a non renewable resource that depletes with time. As extraction proceeds relentlessly, the resource base diminishes and inevitably a point will be reached whereby the remaining resource base is insufficient to maintain current levels of annual extraction. Henceforth annual extraction begins to decline. This phenomenon is known as Peak Oil. As there are several types of oil, each with their own depletion profiles and resource bases, the date at which world oil production will peak is difficult to assess exactly. However, the available scientific evidence indicates that as from 2010, world oil production has been showing signs of peaking.

Hence, the most likely scenario is an extended period of ups and downs in oil production and widely fluctuating oil prices before production dips for good. This is exactly what has happened since 2010. The world is therefore not too far away from entering a period of terminal decline in oil production.

In such a context, to consider long haul tourism as sustainable is out of the question altogether. A declining oil production will drag with it long haul tourism in a maelstrom of declining arrivals and revenues.

It could be argued that somehow alternatives to jet fuel will be found just in time to avert disruptions. Indeed, bio fuels or other synthetic fuels have been tested successfully by a few airlines. However, the airline business consumes about 3 million barrels of oil per day to operate about 25,000 commercial aircrafts. It is hardly credible to think that such alternatives can be ramped up to take up the slack given the volumes of jet fuel required on a daily basis.

It has even been argued that liquid hydrogen may be used as jet fuel. Note that no such aircraft is known to exist, not even as prototypes. The extreme difficulties in handling liquid hydrogen makes the concept of hydrogen powered aircrafts currently unrealistic.

With no credible alternatives to oil as jet fuel and due to Peak Oil, the long haul aviation tourism industry appears to be a sunset industry heading for terminal decline over the next few decades. In all probability, air travel in the future will be restricted to the military, Government officials, very rich tourists, overseas students, and business people or for urgent travel. The Age of cheap air travel is drawing to a close….very soon.
channel33: star cut lantern (Default)
The sustainability of civilisations and the long view of History

In a previous article we argued that modern economic systems require large quantities of raw materials and energy to run and generate equally large quantities of wastes and pollution. Technical efficiencies allow better use of resources per dollar of GDP but economic growth means that on aggregate more resources are required than before.

Sustainable development together with the circular economy and renewable energies are presented as a way out of this conundrum in order to allow the business as usual scenario to prevail. This arrangement is destined to fail as it is very difficult to put in place a circular economy and renewable energies cannot replace oil fully as transport energy. Sustainable development is a dead end that will lead many astray.
Instead, we should focus onto issues of sustainability. Etymologically, the word sustainable comes from the Latin word: sustinere which means to “hold and maintain things from below”. Indeed, what we want to sustain and maintain over the long term is human civilisation.

In our understanding, civilisation ought to be humane, cultured and sustainable. Let us see what we mean by those terms. A humane civilisation is one in which society acts so that individuals are able to meet their basic needs for food, water, energy, shelter and are granted a minimum of basic rights. A cultured civilisation is one that gives reasonable opportunities to its members to access the cultural resources available to it and that means its knowledge and skill bases, whether written or oral, formal or informal. A sustainable civilisation is one which does not undermine its own resource base via inconsiderate actions and short term thinking so characteristic of modern times.
Most readers will more or less agree with our definitions of a humane and cultured civilisation. Hence we shall focus on our understanding of what a sustainable civilisation is. For us this means a society which acts to ensure that (1) its food comes from agricultural and husbandry systems that do not deplete soil and do not depend on artificial fertilisers and that fisheries are not depleted, (2) its water resources stay clean and untainted by industrial systems, (3) its energy system depends on renewable energies, (4) all wastes, liquid or solid, commercial, industrial or domestic are recycled (5) its human population stays more or less constant and above all, (6) its population is not obsessed by the accumulation of wealth and power. Our incessant greed and desire for more wealth is at the core of our predicament. Accumulation of material wealth is incompatible with sustainability. This needs to be understood. As long as we do not address our greed and excessive wants, we are in a self defeating cycle of delusions based on wishful thinking fuelled by fantasies of sustainable development.

Conversely, sustainability does not mean to live as paupers in want and destitution, nor does it mean to live in austerity and self inflicted poverty. It means to strive for a balance between our legitimate needs and our desire for material comforts. It means to honestly re-assess our desire for more material goods.

Do we really need this latest electronic gadget with so much “apps” we shall never use? Do we really need this latest, trendy dress that we shall wear only a few times? Do we really want to travel by air to this far away place for a few days of stressful holidays? We really need to have a long hard look at our own personal consumption habits and see where we are satisfying reasonable needs or, in fact, just feeding the global machine of infinite economic growth. In so doing we might actually save some money and ease our financial burdens.

It bears saying that the path to sustainability is not only for Government or businesses to tread, citizens also are invited to travel down that road. Indeed, the commitment of citizens in changing their modes of consumption is an extremely potent force. Together, concerned citizens can overturn governmental and business practices by (1) buying goods and services that were generated in a more sustainable manner, (2) boycotting goods and services from businesses who fail to change, and (3) by ousting elected officials who promise a lot but deliver little. We should not underestimate the force of non violent collective action. On its own, collective action can change civilisations.

Indeed, civilisations which fail to respond adequately to existential challenges in due time inevitably decline and collapse. In the past, civilisations came and went for a number of reasons. For instance, it is highly probable that both the Roman Western Empire and the Central American Mayan Empire declined and collapsed in part due to environmental reasons, having depleted their agricultural bases and failed to respond adequately. In due time, ours will probably overshoot its main resource bases in terms of fossil energy and agriculture lands. If it fails to respond to the changing circumstances, it will enter decline and face collapse.

However, there are examples of civilisations which just about managed to avoid complete collapse and re-emerge sooner or later. The Egyptian and Chinese civilisations are prime examples. Both of them managed to avoid destroying completely their main resource base which was agriculture, thereby enabling another round of civilisation later on.

We need to do the same: maintain our agricultural base more or less functional so that we can rebound in due time (although re-mergence of a civilisation after collapse may take decades or a few centuries!). Alas, this is exactly what we are not doing. Due to technological prowess, our civilisation behaves as if it could grow indefinitely; perpetually find cheap substitutes for all its material and energy needs and use nature as dumping grounds for ever. Our modern industrial civilisation is hell bent on growth for ever with scant regard for the environment and resources. This type of thinking is leading us straight into the swamps of decline. Humanity will nevertheless emerge on the other side of these swamps but at high costs to people and the environment. We have indeed entered an age of consequences.

Karim Jaufeerally – Institute for Environmental Studies
channel33: star cut lantern (Default)
As the 21st century unfolds, people realise that something is amiss with our modern civilization and this in spite of tremendous advances in sciences, technology and economic welfare over the last 300 years.

In the developed West immense strides in technology and material wealth over the past decades have not resulted in large scale improvements in the quality of life. India and China have improved the human condition there but at great environmental costs that impact human welfare. Similarly, in the rest of the rest of the world improvements in human welfare and economic wealth come at heavy environmental costs.

It is clear that increases in wealth, obtained by destroying part of the environment are no longer sustainable over the short or medium term. Impacts of modern civilisation on the general environment worldwide are on the earth, its waters, its air, its biodiversity and its mineral wealth.

Large tracts of land are laid waste due to deforestation, poor agricultural techniques and intensive husbandry whilst urbanisation is covering increasingly large areas of good agricultural lands.

Most coastal waters and rivers are heavily polluted by liquid and solid wastes from industrial and commercial activities and shipping whilst uncountable masses of plastic debris floating in the seas and kill millions of sea creatures.

Air pollution afflicts most large cities of the world due to heavy vehicular transport and industry with often lethal health impacts whilst climate change slowly melts the poles, glaciers and pushes world climatic systems into more extremes of weather.

The gradual but now virtually unstoppable erosion of biodiversity is undeniable and gravely threatens our food security through the destruction of plant and genetic resources. Major fisheries worldwide are collapsing worldwide beyond repair.

The mineral wealth of the earth has also been significantly spent, including the mineral energy resources of coal, oil and natural gas indispensible to our civilisation. Foremost, conventional oil resources have been severely depleted worldwide thus increasing our dependency on non-conventional oil resources like US light tight oil, deep sea oil, polar arctic oil or bituminous sands from Canada which are difficult to exploit and expensive, hence pushing prices upwards.

The collapse of oil prices from US $ 100 per barrel in 2014 to US $ 70 today may well be a temporary phenomenon. So watch out for oil prices it is well capable of derailing economic growth on its own and of delivering body blows to our civilisation.

Our modern industrial civilisation comes at a heavy environmental price. The bounty of the earth has enabled our civilisation to offset environmental costs. Left unchecked, these costs directly diminish human welfare and trigger political unrest for Governments.

In response during the seventies, many industrialised countries passed legislation and created agencies to address environmental issues. The same phenomenon is now beginning to unfold in China and India after decades of wanton industrialisation and near total disregard for the environment.

In 1987, the Bruntland Commission report launched the “sustainable development” concept in an effort to accommodate environmental stewardship with the juggernaut of development. There are many definitions, but basically sustainable development means “development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs”.

There are considerable philosophical conundrums with that definition. Development refers to a process that has a beginning, middle and an end, whereas sustainable development implies a process with no end in sight. After all, if it is sustainable, why stop?

Furthermore development implies expansion of economic activities and so to increased consumption of material and energy resources. With technical efficiencies it is sometimes possible to reduce resource consumption per monetary unit. Yet the growth of economic systems always outrun technical efficiencies thus aggregate consumption of resources increases.

To circumvent these obvious difficulties, the concept of circular economies has been invented whereby wastes are recycled anew and input back into the economy, similar to what nature does when dead organic matter is decomposed back into nutrients by micro-organisms and used by plants for new growth. However, modern economies recycle little of their wastes especially plastics and many of our technological gadgetry, such as ubiquitous cell phones, tablets, and personal computers, are still technically challenging to recycle.

The greatest and least discussed challenge to a transition to a fully circular economy is energy. Renewable energy is touted as the path to tread for the future. Let us examine that claim. All renewable energies ultimately come from the sun and it is a fact that the surface of the Earth receives from the sun far more energy in an hour than humanity uses in a year.

But then in a rhetorical leap, it is argued that this solar abundance will somehow translate itself into useable forms of energy thanks to technology so that our future is assured.
Yet this energy is diffused across the surface of the Earth and needs to be collected, concentrated and stocked into a useable form. Currently solar energies are exploited via thermal collectors for heat, solar panels or wind turbines for electricity or via biomass.





Liquid fuels essential for modern transports such as cars, lorries, ships or aircrafts are the Achilles’ heel of renewable energies as it is currently not possible to transform solar energies into liquid fuels except via bio-fuels whose available volumes are very small compared to oil based liquid fuels.

The current drive towards electric vehicles is a response to the pesky issue of renewable energies and transport. However, given that there are close to one billion land vehicles and only a few million of electric vehicles worldwide, the full electrification of land vehicles will require decades, even when assuming that it is entirely technically feasible. Reality is that technical hurdles are still extant concerning the power storage capacity, speed of recharge and durability of batteries. As for air and maritime transport there are NO substitutes for oil based fuels given that electrification is currently unfeasible.

In view of the above we can only conclude that sustainable development appears to be a mirage.

Karim Jaufeerally
channel33: star cut lantern (Default)
Mauritius is a fairly well developed country which has progressed considerably over the last 60 years in the economic, political and social spheres. It has adopted, unreservedly, the western model of society in nearly all aspects of human activities.

This model of development has benefitted immensely Mauritian society in terms of higher standards of living. Social markers of human welfare, such as literacy levels, life expectancies and infant mortality have all markedly improved over the past decades.

However, these improvements in human welfare have environmental, health and social costs which are slowly but surely becoming impossible to ignore.

Large increases in economic output were possible by reckless exploitation of local natural resources such as forests, fertile lands, beaches and lagoons. Whilst human welfare rose, there was a concomitant increase in non-communicable diseases, stress and chemical poisoning. Furthermore severe social stresses are becoming widespread as can be seen in the rise of violent crimes, child and spouse abuses for instance.

Nevertheless, Mauritian society has proved itself to be very resilient in the face of such pressures accruing from modernity.

In addition to costly internal dynamics, Mauritian society has to face a number of challenges that come from the rest of the world and from the dysfunctions of our modern industrial civilization (MIC) which emerged in late 18th century England where the industrial revolution first began.

Over the past three centuries, MIC has proved itself to be spectacularly powerful and has conquered the whole world as there are very few regions on Earth that can be said to be exempt from its touch, for the better or the worse.

MIC has 3 main characteristics which are central to its mode of functioning. It is (1) expansionist, (2) linear and (3) mainly dependent on fossil fuels.

(1) Expansionist
Our civilisation has created an economic system that requires growth at any costs. Indeed, growth has become the main concern of Governments, the private sector and citizens. But growth is exponential in nature as it feeds on itself. For instance at a modest rate of 3% annual rate, an economic system doubles its output every 25 years and increases by a factor of 19 over a century. Now to increase economic output year in and year out requires more material resources and energy and generates even more wastes. It is clear that such an exponential system would sooner or later over shoot its own resource base thereby creating intractable problems. Amazingly, over most of the 20th century, the world economy has done just that for certain critical resources like oil, coal and natural gas. However, the available evidence is that major constraints over the supply of these resources are expected during the 21st century. For instance, supply constraints for oil have manifested themselves since 2010 and will continue to do so in the future. Given the non renewable and finite nature of oil, it follows that a point will be reached whereby the remaining resource base will be unable to maintain current production. Therefore annual oil production declines as time goes by. This phenomenon is called Peak Oil. Supply constraints are also expected for coal and natural gas by 2030 or 2040 respectively called Peak Coal or Peak Natural Gas. Similar supply constraints are beginning to show up in global fisheries, forest products, agricultural outputs, diverse minerals and even construction sands.

(2) Linear

The economic system of MIC is mainly linear in functioning meaning that raw natural resources are extracted from the environment, transformed into goods which are subsequently discarded. Although recycling is an important feature of MIC, it is not sufficient to offset the linear nature of our economic system. Hence resources, renewable or not, are slowly but surely and irrevocably depleted beyond points of no return. The current fashion for a circular economy is a belated attempt to remedy the situation. It is a welcomed move but largely insufficient to reverse the massive stream of wastes MIC generates or to reduce depletion of natural resources to a manageable level.

(3) Dependency on fossil fuels

80% of energy used by MIC consists of fossil fuels with declining resource bases. The current world efforts to replace fossil fuels with renewable energies are insufficient to offset impacts of depletion on supply. Furthermore for certain critical uses such as transport it is very difficult to replace oil with renewable energies although electric cars, trains or busses help to some extent. Hence oil supply constraints will lead to intractable transportation issues resulting in severe economic disruptions.

Those 3 characteristics put together mean that MIC is an unsustainable system that will inevitably over shoot its resource base and thus set off severe crisis on multiple fronts. The exact timing and severity of the different crisis are very difficult to pinpoint accurately and will probably vary across different regions in the world. But the near future occurrences of severe crisis are largely unavoidable.

Succinctly, the different crisis happening now or coming soon can be regrouped under the acronym CAFEE, meaning Climatic, Alimentary, and Financial, Energy and Environmental dynamics. Massive uses of fossil fuels generate climate change. The exponential consumption and depletion of natural resources degrade agricultural land, destroy fish stocks and forests that trigger alimentary and environmental crisis whilst Peak Oil generates energy crisis. All dynamics combined create financial instabilities.

Although the whole world is attempting a transition to renewable energies, to consolidate food security and to promote sustainable production of goods and services, it is highly probable that such measures will not prevent severe impacts on human society. This is because (1) our economic system is dependent on exponential growth which neither renewable energy nor sustainable production systems can sustain over the medium or long term and (2) because we are short of time given that the CAFEE crisis has already begun. Any transition to sustainability inevitably takes time given the complexities involved. After all, to retool any economic system is a mighty task.

The main impacts may consist of reduced affordability and availability of Food, Energy and Water (FEW). Although technology has a role to play in mitigating impacts, it cannot be relied upon as the main response to the CAFEE crisis. This is because the situation has been created by our gluttonous modern way of life that demanded ever increasing consumption of energy and resources. Our gluttony cannot be cured by technology.

Reduced affordability and availability of FEW may push the world economic system to breaking point resulting in reduced economic output, lowered standards of living and limited economic opportunities for large sections of the world population. Many societies across the world may experience decline, turmoil and violence resulting in human misery. It is time to plan for the consequences on society of our collective failure to make an orderly transition to sustainable energy and production systems.

Indeed our most potent response to reduce human misery ought to be changes in our patterns of consumption and ways of life as storms gather strength throughout the world. In that respect a deep understanding of the dynamics of society in the current age and throughout History will be critical in crafting intelligent responses to the current CAFEE crisis.

For instance, it would be very worthwhile to examine in detail how societies fared during the difficult years of World War 2 and thereafter. There are lessons therein that could be invaluable to learn for urgent application. Hence inputs from historians, anthropologists and sociologists are important right now in the quest for sustainability. Society needs to hear from these people as the past holds secrets of importance to all of us.
channel33: star cut lantern (starcut lantern)
On Aviation, Oil and Tourism: Glimpses of the Future

Modern mass tourism became a reality in the sixties due to the convergence of a number of factors that mainly arose during World War Two. The victorious allies acquired experience in the design, construction and operation of vast fleets of heavy bombers used in devastating air campaigns against Nazi Germany and Imperial Japan. The simultaneous invention of the jet engine in Germany and Great Britain during the war meant that very powerful engines could be used for long distance air travel. The invention of radar by the UK and Germany enabled safe air traffic control. The allied war effort also required the supply of large volumes of abundant and cheap oil provided by an increasingly sophisticated and capable oil industry. In view of the above, it is striking how tourism owes so much to modern warfare.

After more than 70 years of safe, fast and affordable air travel, Governments, industry and people world wide take the airline industry for granted: readily available and affordable as any modern convenience can be. It is assumed that this will remain so for the foreseeable future. Indeed, Governments across the planet have high hopes for air travel and tourism as engines of future growth.

A basic understanding of energy and technical issues does not allow to have the same optimistic view of the future of air travel. Here is why: Oil is essential for air travel as there are few substitutes given the volumes of liquid fuel required each day. During World War II Nazi Germany successfully used coal to produce significant quantities of aviation fuel. But the process was expensive, required large scale industrial facilities fed by abundant coal, water and cheap labour and produced lower quality aviation fuel compared to oil. Furthermore, Nazi Germany never managed to produce enough fuel for its vast armies, a significant factor in its final defeat.

After the War, Apartheid South Africa set up a coal to liquid fuel industry (that still exists); in part to circumvent the oil embargo it was subjected to from Oil Producing and Exporting Countries (OPEC). In both cases, those inhumane regimes never managed to produce enough liquid fuels for their own uses. Recently there have been efforts to use vegetable oils as feedstock for aviation fuel. Although technically successful the volumes produced are so minute that even if production were to steadily increase over the years and adding liquid fuels from coal from South Africa (and soon from China which intends to set up such an industry there) the world will most probably never produce enough alternative fuels to offset even a modest percentage of its current oil based aviation fuel needs.

On and off there is talk in some quarters about the use of liquid hydrogen as transportation fuel. Alas there are no known safe and economic ways to store and carry large volumes of liquid hydrogen. Also note that it is highly unlikely that there can ever be technological substitute to jet turbines which have proven their worth since World War 2. Hence, it is reasonable to assume that in the coming decades there shall be no substitutes for oil fueled jet turbines in aviation. The fate of aviation and tourism here and elsewhere resides with oil. It is ironic that the capacity of humans to fly to the blue skies depends on oil that gushes forth from the dark hells of the subterranean worlds.
We should therefore ask ourselves what will be the state of oil supply, demand and prices in the coming years. Although it is very difficult to answer those questions precisely, we can shed some light on oil dynamics that may lead to a greater understanding of the situation. Oil, coal and natural gas are finite and non-renewable resources created by natural processes millions of years ago from the slow transformation of biomass buried deep within the earth’s crust. Coal for instance comes mainly from fossilized trees, whereas oil and natural gas from fossilized algae. These natural processes have created immense but finite volumes of coal, oil and natural gas. Each ton of coal, oil or natural gas extracted from within the bowels of the Earth inevitably reduces the remaining volumes.

As volumes in Earth’s crust diminish, a point will be reached thereby the resource is unable to sustain current volumetric production which therefore begins to drop. It is a physical inevitability. As the resource is depleted, production slips year by year until extraction is abandoned for being either economically or technologically non-viable. Production declines can be reversed if new resources are discovered and exploited or if new technologies are used on previously costly and difficult to exploit resources.

An excellent case study is the history of oil production in the US over the last 150 years. The US was one of the first countries to extract oil during the nineteenth century. At first production was on land and from easy to drill oil fields of Pennsylvania or Texas and later on to many other places making the US a leading oil producer. In the forties, oil was extracted from the shallow waters of California. In the sixties, technology enabled oil production in the deeper waters of the Gulf of Mexico and in Alaska.

Then in 1970 US oil production began to slip as depletion gripped many of the large oil fields. It is interesting to note that as US production slipped, the first oil shocks occurred (1973, 1979) with large increases in oil prices that impacted the world economy. But with new production coming on line from the North Sea, Alaska and Siberia during the eighties, prices dropped to acceptable levels for the next 20 years. In the meanwhile US oil production continued to slip relentlessly. From 2004 prices began an upswing that brought them to stellar heights unheard of before, breaking earlier records in constant US $ terms.

In all probability, the high oil prices of the period 2004 to 2014 contributed to the economic crisis of 2008/2009. At the same time, something happened to US oil production as unexpectedly it began to rise steadily as from 2008 whilst oil prices tumbled by 50% in 2015. This reversal of fortune can be explained by the fact that US oil industry began exploiting massively a difficult oil resource known as shale oil or light tight oil. This resource had been known about and exploited since the fifties but its production began to rise spectacularly as from 2008 because of improvements in technology and large influxes of financial capital attracted by high oil prices. After more than a decade of bonanza, oil production from these fields are expected to flatten off in the coming years and then decline as depletion sets in. It will probably drag US oil production down with it.

The point of this story is that eventually oil depletion always wins in spite of immense technical and scientific expertise, capital and will power from oil companies. What happened in the US also happens elsewhere and eventually oil depletion takes over the show world wide. But it does not happen overnight, depletion as an implacable foe wins battle after battle flattening out world oil production, creating price swings, impacting economies the world over and eventually dragging down world oil production.

To some extent, this is what has occurred since the seventies when US oil production dropped, oil prices shot up and economic crisis appeared, to be followed by price collapses in the eighties that lasted 20 years. A new cycle began in 2004 with sharp increases in prices, followed by crashes whilst world oil production flattened out. With the help of shale oil, production is once more increasing. With the war in Ukraine (2022) prices are high once more and nobody can know how long prices will remain high and future violent price swings are inevitable given that depletion never sleeps. Slowly but surely a period of maximum production will be reached followed by a slow and uneven decline stretched over many decades.

Although it is difficult to establish the time frame over which oil production reaches a maximum and subsequently declines, the majority of studies place that event over a 2010 to 2030 period. Very few studies push it to 2030 or beyond. Nevertheless, it is clear that a peak and decline in world oil production occurring within a narrow time frame is extremely likely. We have seen how air travel is irremediably tied to cheap oil; the consequence of this is that as world oil production stagnates and begins its decline, oil prices may become increasingly volatile, rising rapidly to high levels and then crashing just as quickly as demand is destroyed, then the cycle will begin anew as depletion bites further. The impact on air travel will be profound and long lasting. Highly volatile oil prices will cripple air travel and tourism; long haul flights will become increasingly expensive and unaffordable to the majority.

In time, only the very wealthy will be able to fly frequently over long distances, for the majority long haul flights will be rare events. Long haul mass tourism will contract significantly and tourists will probably seek destinations closer to home. We can imagine that in such a context fewer European tourists will travel to far away places like Mauritius but rather opt for Mediterranean destinations. Chinese and other Asian tourists also may opt for closer places to visit like Vietnam, Burma and the Philippines for instance. Indians may still come to Mauritius but in fewer numbers. We do not believe that East Africa will ever become a major source of tourists as poverty is still an issue there and middle class East Africans may not be particularly interested in visiting beaches here similar to what they have in their home countries. The Middle East is in upheaval due to rampant American, European and Israeli interventionism and aggression. Alas, it seems likely that these factors will not abate any time soon and thus it is best not to expect many tourists from that region.

In conclusion, we believe that long haul mass tourism is irremediably tied to cheap and abundant oil. Expensive and less abundant oil spells deep trouble for the tourism industry. Eventually, tourism will return to what it was in the sixties, the privilege of the wealthy upper classes. We do not believe that the tourism industry can face and withstand such a seismic change in oil dynamics. It is bound to end up severely dislocated, a shadow of its current self. Indeed we are currently living in the golden age of mass tourism; enjoy it while you can for it is not destined to last for very long.

Karim Jaufeerally - November 2022.
channel33: star cut lantern (starcut lantern)
Welcome to Channel33!

This is a test only. A real post to come soon.

Keep tuned and thanks!
Page generated Nov. 18th, 2026 09:04 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios